Controversy at Tour of California as Tejay van Garderen allowed to keep leader’s jersey despite losing time
The race jury opted to neutralise the GC after a crash outside the 3km mark
The Tour of California has been hit by a controversy after Tejay van Garderen was allowed to hold onto the race lead, despite losing time on stage four.
EF Education rider Van Garderen was hit by a mechanical inside the final 10km and was forced to chase down the peloton but did not make it back into the bunch.
The peloton were then affected by a crash just outside the 3km mark, causing more time splits.
At the finish, Deceuninck – Quick-Step’s Kasper Asgreen was the race leader-in-waiting after Van Garderen finished 54 seconds back and Gianni Moscon (Team Ineos) also slipped off the podium after being caught in the crash.
Quick-Step's Fabio Jakobsen won the sprint at the line, taking the team's third consecutive stage win in California.
Then an hour after after stage finish, race officials announced that all riders affected by the collision and Van Garderen would be given the same time as the front finishers.
>>> Five talking points from stage five of the Giro d’Italia 2019
Get The Leadout Newsletter
The latest race content, interviews, features, reviews and expert buying guides, direct to your inbox!
The commissaires panel said: “The mass crash near the finish of stage four was just outside the 3km to go point.
“The commissaires have decided to treat the crash such that all riders affected by the incident and the road blockage will receive field time.”
That decision has caused a stir, as many have pointed out the crash happened outside the 3km safety zone and that Van Garderen had not rejoined the bunch by the finish.
Quick-Step boss Patrick Lefevere said on Twitter: “This is a very dangerous precedent and I’m absolute against this decision.”
He added: “Regulations are there to be respected. Now the VAR commissaires will also decide who wins the race.
“Totally unfair against the boys who were fighting for the win.”
>>> Watch: Rémi Cavagna’s sketchy descending while riding to Tour of California solo victory
The official rules say that a rider or riders involved in a crash or who suffer a puncture or mechanical incident inside the last 3km will be given the same finishing time as the group they were with at the time of the problem.
Rules also state that the president of the commissaires’ panel can also decide to cancel or let the results stand if a race is temporarily neutralised or stopped, taking into account the gaps recorded at the moment of the incident.
But the UCI rules are not clear about whether the panel can neutralise the time gaps because of a crash outside the 3km mark, or whether they can give a rider the same time as the bunch if he had not rejoined.
Van Garderen leads the race by six seconds over Moscon, with Asgreen one second further back.
Thank you for reading 20 articles this month* Join now for unlimited access
Enjoy your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription
Join now for unlimited access
Try first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
Alex Ballinger is editor of BikeBiz magazine, the leading publication for the UK cycle industry, and is the former digital news editor for CyclingWeekly.com. After gaining experience in local newsrooms, national newspapers and in digital journalism, Alex found his calling in cycling, first as a reporter, then as news editor responsible for Cycling Weekly's online news output, and now as the editor of BikeBiz. Since pro cycling first captured his heart during the 2010 Tour de France (specifically the Contador-Schleck battle) Alex covered three Tours de France, multiple editions of the Tour of Britain, and the World Championships, while both writing and video presenting for Cycling Weekly. He also specialises in fitness writing, often throwing himself into the deep end to help readers improve their own power numbers. Away from the desk, Alex can be found racing time trials, riding BMX and mountain bikes, or exploring off-road on his gravel bike. He’s also an avid gamer, and can usually be found buried in an eclectic selection of books.
-
My 200-mile Welsh adventure left me crying in a convenience store - but I'd do it again
Looking for a challenging two-day tour, Steve Shrubsall heads to the wild Pembrokeshire coast of Wales (UK) – and gets exactly what he wished for…
By Stephen Shrubsall Published
-
Cranks that whiz at high speed are not a desirable feature, they’re just an invitation for crud to get into the bearings
CW’s Undercover Mechanic turns his attention to the murky world of bottom bracket ‘optimisations’
By Undercover Mechanic Published
-
Tour of California won’t be held in 2020
The Tour of California will not be held in 2020, the race organiser has announced.
By Alex Ballinger Published
-
Record-breaker Tadej Pogačar wins Tour of California after Cees Bol takes stage seven
Slovenian Tadej Pogačar successfully defends his yellow jersey as Cees Bol wins the seventh and final 2019 Tour of California stage
By Chris Marshall-Bell Published
-
Elisa Balsamo wins frantic stage three as Anna van der Breggen wraps up Tour of California GC
Italian rider Elisa Bolsamo continues her good form, while Anna van der Breggen repeats her 2017 triumph
By Chris Marshall-Bell Published
-
Brilliant Tadej Pogačar rides into Tour of California lead after thrilling stage six win
The UAE-Team Emirates rider beat Sergio Higuita of EF-Education First to ride into the yellow jersey
By Chris Marshall-Bell Published
-
Dominant Boels-Dolmans score one-two as Anna van der Breggen closes in on Women's Tour of California victory
Katie Hall won stage two of the Women's Tour of California, with her Boels-Dolmans team-mate Anna van der Breggen finishing second to maintain her lead in yellow
By Chris Marshall-Bell Published
-
'It sets a dangerous precedent': Tour of California riders react to controversial UCI ruling
The UCI commissaires allowed Tejay van Garderen to maintain his overall lead despite getting caught in a crash outside of the 3km mark
By Sophie Smith Published
-
Anna van der Breggen solos to brilliant Tour of California stage one victory
World champion Anna van der Breggen timed her attack perfectly to put her in pole position to repeat her 2017 win
By Chris Marshall-Bell Published
-
Bahrain-Merida's Iván Cortina wins Tour of California stage five
Tejay van Garderen (EF-Education First) maintains his lead in the general classification, though it has been cut to four seconds
By Chris Marshall-Bell Published