'If what happened to Marcel Kittel had happened to me, then I wouldn't be riding discs today'
Rider representative Adam Hansen doubts whether the cut to Owain Doull's shoe could have been caused by race barriers
Riders' union representative Adam Hansen (Lotto-Soudal) said that if he was in Marcel Kittel's position then he would not be riding disc brakes on stage two of the Abu Dhabi Tour.
Kittel was involved in a crash with Team Sky's Owain Doull on stage one of the race, with Doull saying that cuts to his foot and shoe were caused by the disc brakes on the German's bike.
Hansen said that he will be interested to see which bike Kittel chooses to use on stage two, saying that if he himself was in the same situation then he would use a bike with rim brakes, even if it is yet to be proven that a disc brake rotor did indeed cause Doull's injuries.
>>> Riders react on Twitter after Owain Doull blames disc brakes for injury
"I wonder how Kittel feels about it, and I don't want to pick on him, but how does he feel about a rider blaming him for it?" Hansen, the Professional Cyclists Association (CPA) union representative in the Abu Dhabi Tour, told Cycling Weekly.
"I wonder what bike he will ride next time? To me, it would show much more than anything else if he used rim brakes. He has a choice.
"If that happened to me, I would not be riding disc brakes. I wouldn't want other people in that type of risk."
Get The Leadout Newsletter
The latest race content, interviews, features, reviews and expert buying guides, direct to your inbox!
That is advice that Kittel has decided to heed, with the German choosing to start the second stage of the Abu Dhabi Tour on a rim brake bike.
Watch: what do pro riders really think of disc brakes?
Some questioned whether a rotor cut Doull's foot, and after the Emirati dust settled at the finish of stage one, won by Mark Cavendish (Dimension Data), videos and photographs began to fly around the internet.
Hansen discussed whether Doull's injuries could have been caused by the leg of a rusty barrier surrounding the flamme rouge which the riders appeared to collide with in the crash.
The Australian said that in his opinion it was difficult to see a barrier causing the cuts the Doull's shoe and foot.
"It went through two layers of his shoe, the inner layer and leather. If was a jersey or shorts, that would've been bad.
"It is a clean cut, but no barrier I've looked at had something that could cut like that. It could seriously harm you and you could break bones on it, but to cut leather? No."
"When there is a crash, bikes get thrown around, it is not that they just go A to B. They bounce off of riders or walls, so it's really hard to determine that it was not the disc. It looks like there was a crash, there was disc brakes involved and there's a pretty clean cut on a rider."
>>> Watch: Owain Doull shows injuries to his foot after Abu Dhabi Tour crash (video)
The UCI allowed cyclists and teams to use disc brakes for 2017 despite some concerns and a crash last year in Paris-Roubaix, where Francisco Ventoso alleged that an injury to his leg had been caused by a disc brake rotor.
Quick-Step Floors led the way into 2017. Tom Boonen became the first professional to win on disc brakes in the Tour de San Juan and said that he will use them until he retires this spring following Paris-Roubaix.
The CPA said that the UCI is not listening to the riders' feedback. It conducted a poll and Hansen said showed 40 per cent of professional riders are completely against using disc brakes, 40 per cent are against them until better safety measures are adopted, and 16% want to keep using them.
"I can't speak for the other teams, but I've heard that there is some pressure from some teams, or more the sponsors, to use disc brakes. We are lucky with Campagnolo - Campagnolo and Ridley give us the choice. There is no pressure at all," added Hansen.
"We want the lightest bikes possible. Disc brakes add a lot of weight, around a kilogram. It just seems strange to me that riders want the lightest bikes, and disc brakes are the opposite of that.
"Yes, training by yourself in the wet, they are better, but I imagine that no rider would want to be in a crash with bikes having discs."
The CPA and UCI continue to send letters back and forth while the riders continue to race, mostly using caliper brakes, in the Abu Dhabi Tour. Hansen has riders approaching him often complaining about the discs, but said that they will not strike. Instead, he trusts that the union's muscle will bring a fast solution.
Thank you for reading 20 articles this month* Join now for unlimited access
Enjoy your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription
Join now for unlimited access
Try first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
Gregor Brown is an experienced cycling journalist, based in Florence, Italy. He has covered races all over the world for over a decade - following the Giro, Tour de France, and every major race since 2006. His love of cycling began with freestyle and BMX, before the 1998 Tour de France led him to a deep appreciation of the road racing season.
-
TrainingPeaks acquires virtual cycling platform indieVelo, aims to add ‘credible racing and realistic riding’ to its training offerings
Called TrainingPeaks Virtual it will be offered as part of TrainingPeaks Premium in March 2025, with a beta version available now
By Luke Friend Published
-
'In the summer I’ll also jump into a hot bath for 20 minutes after a ride': A week in training with a WorldTour rider
We caught up with Australian Chris Harper as he prepared for this summer's Vuelta a España
By Chris Marshall-Bell Published
-
Ineos Grenadiers say they will work with British Cycling to get Tour of Britain back on ‘as quickly as possible’
Ben Swift and Owain Doull both say it would be a "shame" were the Tour of Britain to be no more
By Adam Becket Published
-
Men’s elite road race halted by protest at World Championships
Scottish environmental group This Is Rigged claim responsibility for the disruption
By Tom Thewlis Published
-
Marcel Kittel: ‘I believe in Mark Cavendish'
The 14 time Tour de France stage winner backs Manxman to grab record breaking 35th stage win in the coming days
By Tom Thewlis Published
-
Tim Merlier doubles up in UAE Tour’s final sprint showdown on stage six
Soudal Quick-Step have now won three stages, with Remco Evenepoel leading the GC into the final day
By Tom Davidson Published
-
Molano sprints to stage four victory at UAE Tour to save UAE Team Emirates' race
Colombian rider wins stage for home team at fourth opportunity, as Remco Evenepoel continues in race lead
By Adam Becket Published
-
Remco Evenepoel edges closer to UAE Tour lead as Soudal Quick-Step win stage two team time trial
The Belgian team won by a single second, leaving Evenepoel tied on time at the top of the GC
By Tom Davidson Published
-
‘That’s not bad’ - Mark Cavendish pleased with first podium finish for Astana at UAE Tour
The British road champion recorded his best race result since joining Astana Qazaqstan
By Tom Davidson Published
-
Tim Merlier declared winner of UAE Tour stage one in tight photo finish
The Soudal Quick-Step rider's team-mate Remco Evenepoel stretched out an early lead in the battle for GC
By Tom Davidson Published